Dynasty Fantasy Football Trade Values: Risers & Fallers to Buy or Sell

The latest dynasty trade value discussion highlighted several players whose stock is changing as we move deeper into startup draft season. While there were no massive shifts across the rankings, a handful of names generated plenty of debate, particularly at quarterback, wide receiver, and tight end. Here are risers and fallers including players to buy or sell in fantasy football.

Dynasty Fantasy Football Trade Values: Why Drake Maye, A.J. Brown, and Colston Loveland Are Climbing

Here are the biggest dynasty takeaways from the latest trade value update.

Drake Maye (QB – NE) Continues to Challenge for QB1

One of the more interesting conversations centered around Drake Maye‘s standing among dynasty quarterbacks.

With A.J. Brown now officially in New England, some managers might expect Maye to move into the unquestioned QB1 spot. That wasn’t necessarily the consensus. While some rankers already had Maye at the top, there remains a strong argument for keeping Josh Allen ahead of him.

The case for Allen is simple. Few players at any position have delivered the level of year-over-year fantasy consistency he has provided. Even with some concerns about how much of his fantasy production relies on rushing touchdowns, Allen remains one of the safest assets in dynasty football.

Maye’s appeal comes from the combination of youth and upside. The belief is that he already belongs in the same tier as Allen, Lamar Jackson, and the other elite fantasy quarterbacks. Whether he ultimately becomes the dynasty QB1 depends on how much managers value long-term projection versus proven production.

Josh Jacobs (RB – GB) Presents a Buy-Low Opportunity

Josh Jacobs was one of the biggest fallers in the updated running back values.

The decline is tied largely to off-field uncertainty, but there are additional concerns. Jacobs is getting older, battled injuries last season, and has never been a major contributor as a pass catcher.

Still, there are reasons dynasty managers shouldn’t completely write him off.

Since arriving in Green Bay, Jacobs has been one of the league’s most reliable touchdown scorers. The Packers consistently lean on him near the goal line, and that role continues to drive fantasy value.

For contenders willing to accept some risk, Jacobs could become one of the more interesting buy-low targets in dynasty leagues.

Bijan Robinson (RB – ATL) and Jahmyr Gibbs (RB – DET) Remain First-Round Startup Assets

Running backs are often difficult to value in dynasty startups because of their shorter career arcs and elevated injury risk.

Even so, both Bijan Robinson and Jahmyr Gibbs were discussed as legitimate first-round startup selections.

The preferred approach remains building around quarterbacks and elite wide receivers early. However, Robinson and Gibbs have reached the point where passing on them simply because they play running back may be a mistake.

The recommendation was not to build an entire roster around running backs. Instead, securing one elite option and then focusing on quarterback and wide receiver depth in the following rounds was viewed as a reasonable strategy.

A.J. Brown (WR – NE) Still Carries Significant Dynasty Value

A.J. Brown‘s move to New England generated one of the most important discussions of the episode.

Even at nearly 29 years old, Brown remains a highly impactful dynasty asset. The optimism stems largely from his pairing with Drake Maye, who is viewed as a talented young passer capable of supporting high-end fantasy production.

The expectation is that Brown should command a massive target share in New England’s offense. While his absolute peak years may be limited, there is still confidence that he can deliver strong production in the near term.

For rebuilding teams, the hosts viewed a projected late 2027 first-round pick as a fair return in a trade. Contending teams, however, may be better served holding Brown and seeing whether a strong start boosts his value even further during the season.

Jeremiah Smith‘s Future Dynasty Value Is Already Creating Buzz

Few prospects generated more excitement than Jeremiah Smith.

The discussion wasn’t about his current value but where he could land once he officially enters dynasty rankings.

There was speculation that Smith could immediately debut as a top-10 dynasty wide receiver and potentially climb even higher depending on how his final collegiate season unfolds.

The comparison wasn’t made lightly. Smith was discussed alongside some of the most exciting wide receiver prospects of the modern era, illustrating just how highly dynasty analysts already view his long-term ceiling.

Makai Lemon (WR – PHI) Is Rising Fast

Makai Lemon continues to gain momentum in dynasty circles.

The conversation highlighted how close Lemon’s value has moved to established NFL producers like Devonta Smith. While that may sound aggressive, the belief is that Lemon’s talent profile justifies the enthusiasm.

His route-running ability and overall skill set have drawn comparisons to Amon-Ra St. Brown, and there is optimism that he could become a high-volume producer early in his career.

The takeaway wasn’t that Lemon is guaranteed to outperform Devonta Smith. Rather, the gap between them may be much smaller than many dynasty managers currently believe.

Colston Loveland (TE – CHI) Is Emerging as an Elite Dynasty Tight End

No player generated more excitement at the tight end position than Colston Loveland.

The discussion made it clear that some dynasty rankers already value Loveland ahead of Trey McBride, placing him directly behind Brock Bowers among dynasty tight ends.

The optimism comes from Loveland’s late-season production surge and the belief that Chicago’s target distribution could create a massive opportunity for him moving forward.

For managers drafting startups this summer, the recommendation was straightforward: if Loveland falls outside the first three rounds, there may be significant value available.

Kyle Pitts (TE – ATL) Still Has Something to Prove

Kyle Pitts remains one of dynasty football’s most polarizing players.

On one hand, he is still only 25 years old and is coming off a productive season. On the other hand, dynasty managers have spent years waiting for the true breakout that never fully arrived.

The discussion acknowledged that Pitts could absolutely improve on last season’s production. However, many rankers remain hesitant to fully buy in until he delivers another strong year.

For now, dynasty managers appear content treating Pitts as a talented player who still needs to prove last season wasn’t an outlier.

Oronde Gadsden II (TE – LAC) Loses Momentum

Oronde Gadsden II was the biggest tight end faller in the rankings.

The concern isn’t necessarily talent. Instead, it’s opportunity.

Additional competition for snaps and targets has created uncertainty about Gadsden’s path to consistent fantasy relevance. While he flashed upside during a brief stretch last season, dynasty managers are now questioning whether he’ll see enough playing time to become a reliable TE1.

That uncertainty pushed his value down despite the intriguing flashes he showed previously.

Fantasy Football Takeaways: Dynasty Trade Values

Drake Maye belongs in the elite dynasty quarterback tier and continues to gain momentum.
Josh Allen remains the safest quarterback asset due to his long track record of fantasy production.
Josh Jacobs carries risk but could be a worthwhile buy-low target for contenders.
Bijan Robinson and Jahmyr Gibbs deserve first-round consideration in dynasty startup drafts.
A.J. Brown‘s move to New England keeps him firmly in the WR2 conversation with upside for more.
Rebuilding teams can reasonably explore moving Brown for future first-round draft capital.
Jeremiah Smith‘s future dynasty value could rival the very best receiver prospects in recent memory.
Makai Lemon is rapidly climbing rankings and may be closer to Devonta Smith than many managers realize.
Colston Loveland is becoming one of the most coveted young tight ends in dynasty formats.
Kyle Pitts remains a high-upside player, but dynasty managers still want another season of proof.
Oronde Gadsden II faces enough playing-time concerns to justify a slight dynasty downgrade.