Following the NFL Draft, the rookie landscape is tougher to project than most years. Outside of Shedeur Sanders‘ draft stock tumbling over the three-day event, there weren’t many surprises or landing spots that will alter the pre-draft assessment of these rookies.
After the top pick, each prospect comes with a side of question marks. There is, however, tons of upside on the board. So, let’s take a look at my first dynasty rookie mock draft, Superflex edition. And be sure to practice dynasty rookie drafts using our dynasty rookie mock draft simulator.
- Dynasty Fantasy Football Draft Kit
- Dynasty Rookie Draft Simulator
- DBro’s Dynasty Rookie Draft Primers
Superflex Dynasty Rookie Mock Draft
1.01: Ashton Jeanty (RB – LV)
The top pick in rookie drafts will be as unanimous as it was in 2023, when Bijan Robinson was the prize of the class. A similar prospect to Robinson, Ashton Jeanty was selected a couple of spots higher at sixth overall by the Las Vegas Raiders.
Although the Raiders have fielded one of the worst offensive lines in the league over the last few seasons, they added to it in free agency and the draft, overhauling the offense as a whole. Geno Smith will help make this a functional passing attack. Brock Bowers and Jeanty represent two of the top young weapons at their respective positions, and we should see this group increase its scoring output in 2025.
The reality is it didn’t matter much where Jeanty landed, he was going to be the consensus 1.01 regardless, like he was in this fantasy football mock draft.
1.02: Cam Ward (QB – TEN)
In a weaker quarterback draft, there are questions about Cam Ward and how good he can be at the NFL level. He would not have been the top pick in many other drafts, but I feel he’s being discounted a bit because of that, and I have questions about every other prospect in this class.
Typically, the top of Superflex rookie drafts are littered with quarterbacks, and Ward has all the tools to become a plus starter in the league. His mechanics aren’t perfect, but most rookies aren’t. He’s not afraid to rip a sidearm, off-balance throw through a tight window, which is celebrated when No. 15 in red does it.
You won’t mistake him for Lamar Jackson, but Ward is mobile and moves especially well in the pocket, similar to Ben Roethlisberger or Steve McNair if he gets moving. He’s not afraid to push the ball downfield and uncork the long ball, which he does with accuracy. He’s not the sure thing we hope for at the top of rookie drafts, but even the best quarterback prospects bust sometimes. I feel good about Ward’s chances of becoming a true franchise quarterback.
1.03: Travis Hunter (WR – JAX)
Like I said, I have questions about the rest of the prospects in this class, but most of those questions revolve around the players’ ability. That is not the case with Travis Hunter, whose talent is a slam dunk. The question here is how many snaps he plays on offense versus defense.
The immediate plan for the second overall pick is to focus on offense first and eventually be ready to go on defense when the season starts. With his initial concentration on wide receiver, it’s fair to believe that will be the priority as he begins his NFL career.
Purely as a receiver prospect, there are very few holes in Hunter’s game. His upside is too much to pass on in comparison to what the other rookies provide. I’m as high on Brian Thomas Jr. as anybody, but the two of them have an opportunity to be lethal together under Liam Coen.
1.04: Omarion Hampton (RB – LAC)
A running back with first-round draft capital is typically a safe bet for a high volume of touches, if nothing else. Omarion Hampton joining Jim Harbaugh’s Chargers is a terrific fit for the style of play the ol’ ball coach likes to see. It’s not ideal that the Bolts signed Najee Harris earlier this offseason, but just to a one-year contract, and Hampton is likely to be a superior runner and take over the bulk of the touches by season’s end.
My biggest complaint with Hampton is his upright, stiff running style. He’s a big back at 221 pounds but can get up and go, sporting a 4.46 40-yard dash time. At times, his tape reminds me of DeMarco Murray; other times, it prompts visions of Ryan Mathews. I have no problem taking Hampton with the second or third pick, but I don’t love him quite as much as I wanted to during the draft process.
1.05: Tetairoa McMillan (WR – CAR)
Tetairoa McMillan posted an absurd amount of production during his three seasons at the University of Arizona, going over 1,300 yards in each of the last two seasons. McMillan is a big-bodied X receiver who snatches the ball out of the air, excelling in contested catch situations. He now has the draft capital to support his strong profile after going eighth overall to Carolina.
Still, I have concerns about his lack of separation ability and his athletic profile. Outside of high-pointing the football, which is a big deal, McMillan doesn’t do anything at an elite level. Perhaps his all-around game will flourish with Bryce Young, and he should see plenty of targets in Carolina, but he falls short of other top receivers we’re used to seeing at the top of rookie drafts.
1.06: Quinshon Judkins (RB – CLE)
Drafted with the fourth pick of the second round, Quinshon Judkins exhibits one of the best profiles paired with a landing spot of the entire draft class. Jerome Ford had his moments over the last couple of seasons, but Cleveland needed an every-down back, and Judkins fits the bill as one of the most well-rounded backs in the class.
Although his running style is based on physicality more than finesse, Judkins offers a strong blend of size and speed. At 221 pounds, Judkins’ 4.48 40-yard dash puts him in the 75th percentile among running backs while his broad jump (132″) and vertical jump (38.5″) land in the 98th and 89th percentile, respectively.
Judkins is unlikely to make many NFL defenders miss, but he’s explosive and strong through the line of scrimmage and will create yards after contact with his tough running style. He’s not the same level of talent as former Brown Nick Chubb, but he offers a similar style of play. The Browns’ selection of Dylan Sampson hurts Judkins’ case of playing on third downs, but he’s a capable pass-catcher who should lead this backfield immediately.
1.07: Colston Loveland (TE – CHI)
My favorite pairing of the NFL Draft is Colston Loveland and the Chicago Bears. Not only was Loveland selected ahead of Tyler Warren, but he found himself a dream landing spot in the process. While there is plenty of competition for targets, and Cole Kmet remains on the roster, Loveland’s pairing with Ben Johnson and Caleb Williams outweighs those concerns.
DJ Moore and Rome Odunze figure to start on the outside, but starting slot receiver Keenan Allen is no longer with the club. The Bears added Luther Burden in the second round, and he’s a candidate for the slot role, but Loveland should see plenty of work out of the slot with Kmet lined up inline. With Burden and Kmet on board, Johnson can be creative with Loveland, lining him up in the slot or inline, with or without Kmet, and can use pre-snap motions to find advantageous matchups.
The knock against Loveland is primarily centered around his blocking, but the 6-foot-6 tight end operates like a wideout with his route running and speed, consistently showing the ability to separate and create mismatches for his offense. Johnson made the most of another tight end with similar concerns in Sam LaPorta, and I expect him to do the same with Loveland.
1.08 – Matthew Golden (WR – GB)
After two years at Houston, Matthew Golden spent last season with the Texas Longhorns, where he turned himself into a first-round pick. His college stats don’t jump off the page, but his potential popped in the College Football Playoff (CFP). In his last four games, including the SEC Championship and three playoff games, Golden tallied 411 receiving yards on 3.37 yards per route run.
Golden can fly with a 4.29 40-yard dash that puts him in the 100th percentile among wide receivers. His route running needs some refinement, but he runs a full route tree and can run past defenders with ease. His ball skills play well beyond his 5-foot-11 frame, with a penchant for making spectacular grabs. Although the Green Bay offense is crowded, the team lacks a top option.
Christian Watson will miss a significant portion of the 2025 season, and Dontayvion Wicks has fumbled his opportunities. Romeo Doubs will likely claim one of the outside spots, and Jayden Reed is limited to the slot, leaving room for Golden to immediately become a go-to player. Capable of playing inside or outside, Golden will likely play on the outside primarily, which will keep him on the field in 2-WR sets.
1.09: TreVeyon Henderson (RB – NE)
TreVeyon Henderson shared the Ohio State backfield with Quinshon Judkins and may be on a similar path in the NFL. An extremely gifted runner and receiver out of the backfield, the question with Henderson is how much work he can handle at the NFL level. Although I believe he can handle a bigger role, Henderson will shine on third downs as a pass-catcher.
With Rhamondre Stevenson in town and Josh McDaniels’ history of utilizing a third-down back, it seems likely Henderson will start in that role. He’s extremely twitchy with quick acceleration and is a quality route runner with soft hands. Henderson does a good job of sneaking through creases along the line to get into the second level, but he’s not an ideal short-yardage back.
In PPR leagues, Henderson could return value immediately, but in standard scoring leagues, he will need to garner some early-down carries.
1.10: Jaxson Dart (QB – NYG)
Brian Daboll and the New York Giants had long been linked to Jaxson Dart and made a move to get back into the first round on Thursday night to select the Ole Miss quarterback. The Giants have taken the approach of throwing as many darts, no pun intended, at the position this offseason, signing Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston before the selection of Dart.
The Giants have stated Wilson will be their starter this season, but it remains to be seen how long that will last when Mr. Unlimited shows off his limitations. Dart has all the tools of a franchise quarterback, boasting a very strong arm and an underrated athletic profile. He will bring value with his legs, but his decision-making needs to mature for him to take over the No. 1 QB role.
Being paired with Daboll is an ideal fit, and if he can harness his big arm, Dart has a chance to be a quality starting quarterback.
1.11: RJ Harvey (RB – DEN)
It’s easy to fall in love with the landing spot rather than the player, and there’s certainly a risk of that with RJ Harvey. Although many had him further down the board, Sean Payton got his guy in the second round and will look to mold Harvey into his very own joker. Payton has a history of maximizing running backs with strong pass-catching skills, particularly smaller backs.
Beyond the landing spot, there’s a lot to like about Harvey, particularly when you turn on his tape. At just 5-foot-8, Harvey is built like a brick and unafraid to take on contact and run through it. He has loads of burst and can get up and go, sporting a 4.4 40-yard dash, good enough for the 96th percentile.
Harvey handled a big workload at UCF, averaging over 130 rushing yards per game in 2024 and averaging 1.44 yards per route run over his collegiate career. The rookie will share some work with Audric Estime and Jaleel McLaughlin, but is the early favorite to lead the backfield in Denver.
1.12: Tyler Warren (TE – IND)
Tyler Warren may be a better NFL prospect than a fantasy football prospect with his blocking profile, but that brings an added benefit of staying on the field full time. There are some hesitations around a five-year college tight end making the jump to the NFL, but Warren is different and should command a large target share in Indianapolis.
The biggest question is who will be throwing the ball to him and how accurate those targets will be, but he offers incredible play strength and toughness at the catch point. His versatility will allow him to line up around the formation and his quickness will get him open underneath, which will bode well for Anthony Richardson or Daniel Jones. Warren will have a chance to be in the TE1 mix immediately.
Subscribe: YouTube | Spotify | Apple Podcasts | iHeart | Castbox | Podcast Addict | TuneIn
