Dynasty Rookie Mock Draft: 10-Team, Superflex (2025 Fantasy Football)

Dynasty rookie draft season is officially upon us. Now that the final piece of the puzzle (draft capital) has been added to rookie prospect profiles, we can start to pin down our fantasy football rankings to maximize value.

I’ve put together a two-round dynasty rookie mock draft to help you navigate through the early portion of your rookie drafts. This fantasy mock draft is based on a 10-team Superflex format with PPR scoring. Let’s take a look at who made my top 20.

Dynasty Rookie Mock Draft

Round 1

1.01 – Ashton Jeanty (RB – LV)

This past season, Ashton Jeanty led the FBS in rushing yards, rushing touchdowns, yards after contact, missed tackles forced and Pro Football Focus (PFF) run grade. Not much else needs to be said. He’s the 1.01 in all formats and in a tier of his own.

1.02 – Travis Hunter (WR/CB – JAX)

Jacksonville’s front office stated they see Travis Hunter primarily as an offensive player and plan to install some packages on defense for him. This is great news for fantasy purposes.

I’ve heard some people voice concerns about whether there will be enough volume for Hunter and Brian Thomas Jr. to both be top options in fantasy. This is just a misunderstanding of how target distribution works. Teams are going to throw to their best players first. This will only hurt guys like Parker Washington and Brenton Strange; the big dogs eat first.

Liam Coen was able to get the most out of Chris Godwin and Mike Evans last year when healthy, and this new Jacksonville duo is objectively more talented at this point in everyone’s career. I trust Coen to have this offense running like a well-oiled machine.

1.03 – Omarion Hampton (RB – LAC)

Few things are more bullish for a running back than first-round draft capital on a Jim Harbaugh-led offense. Omarion Hampton was the entire offense for North Carolina the past two seasons, proving he can take on an NFL workhorse role.

Don’t worry about Najee Harris. He’s on a one-year deal for backup money. Hampton will own this backfield by mid-season.

1.04 – Tetairoa McMillan (WR – CAR)

Tetairoa McMillan is an early-declare and an early breakout, totalling over 1,400 receiving yards and 10 touchdowns as a true sophomore. Despite the Arizona Wildcats’ offense being pretty terrible, he posted a similar stat line in 2024 as well.

McMillan earned top-10 draft capital and is walking into a situation in Carolina where he should be the No. 1 WR from Day 1. The floor with McMillan is insanely high. He has top-five upside.

1.05 – Quinshon Judkins (RB – CLE)

I am fully aware of Quinshon Judkins’ red flags when it comes to per-touch efficiency metrics. He is not particularly impressive after contact, lacks elusiveness and his career yards per route run as a receiver (0.76) is well below average.

Judkins is far from a flawless prospect, but he lands on a Cleveland Browns team where he can quickly establish himself as a three-down back. Judkins is an early-declare, posted a 9.87 relative athletic score (RAS) and was the third running back off the board in a loaded draft class. The pros outweigh the cons.

1.06 – Cam Ward (QB – TEN)

In a 12-team league, I would have Cam Ward as my 1.05 and would consider him even higher on quarterback-needy teams. That said, quarterbacks are easier to come by in a 10-team league. There are enough starting signal-callers for every team in the league to roster three. That puts a discount on Ward, especially due to his lack of fantasy production on the ground.

Ward’s creativity and ability to make something out of nothing are reminiscent of Patrick Mahomes. If Tennessee can surround Ward with some real offensive weapons, he may become a force to be reckoned with.

1.07 – Colston Loveland (TE – CHI)

Initially, I was a bit grossed out by this landing spot, but my friend and colleague @force_fantasy was the voice of reason and helped me realize this could be an excellent situation for Colston Loveland.

At the end of the day, Chicago liked him enough to draft him 10th overall. Ben Johnson has a plan, and that plan includes Loveland.

I’ll bet on the talent here. Loveland’s film was maybe my favorite to watch all offseason. He’s essentially a wide receiver with tight end strength and can make some absurd grabs.

1.08 – TreVeyon Henderson (RB – NE)

Consensus is that TreVeyon Henderson is a better dynasty bet than Quinshon Judkins. If I have to reach to get a share or two for my dynasty portfolio, I’m willing to do that.

That said, I’d take Judkins in a vacuum. Henderson is a four-year player with a history of injuries. He’ll need to rely more on efficiency to hit from a fantasy perspective, as he’s not a workhorse by nature.

If I’m set at tight end and quarterback, I’d be willing to take Henderson above Ward and Loveland. He’s a freshman breakout with second-round draft capital who gets to play with Drake Maye. There are plenty of reasons to be bullish.

1.09 – Tyler Warren (TE – IND)

The 2024 John Mackey Award winner is off to Indianapolis — one of the more disappointing landing spots for a pass-catcher. From a fantasy perspective, if you have Tyler Warren on your team, you’re almost hoping for Daniel Jones to win the job over Anthony Richardson.

We can all agree the landing spot sucks, but as we say in dynasty: Talent over situation. Warren is still a big, versatile athlete who can pour on the fantasy points. Who knows, maybe the Colts draft Arch Manning in the 2026 NFL Draft, catapulting Warren to the Brock Bowers tier.

1.10 – Emeka Egbuka (WR – TB)

Speaking of talent over situation, Emeka Egbuka may feel like a difficult click at the 1.10 given the target competition in Tampa Bay this coming season. They already have a slot receiver in Chris Godwin, so the plan here is unclear.

I think the Buccaneers front office went with the “best guy available” strategy with Egbuka, knowing he’ll be a difference-maker for the franchise eventually. Drafting Egbuka requires patience, but it could pay massive dividends when Mike Evans and Chris Godwin age out.

That closes out my first round of picks in this Superflex rookie mock draft. Below are my round two selections, minus explanations.

Round 2

More Rookie Mock Drafts

Thank you for checking out my article today. If you have any dynasty or rookie-related questions, feel free to send me a DM on X @jim_DFF. Time to dominate your rookie drafts.