Skip to main content

Fantasy Baseball Draft Closer Outlook: Team-by-Team (2024)

Fantasy Baseball Draft Closer Outlook: Team-by-Team (2024)

The closer position has always been a bit of a controversial position from a fantasy baseball perspective with everyone valuing it differently. It is a position I often tend to punt in most drafts with a number of closers emerging on the waiver wire every year. However, drafting an anchor dominant closer can certainly be beneficial.

Below is a team-by-team look at every team’s closer situation as we sit here towards the end of February.

Team-by-Team Closer Outlook

American League East

Craig Kimbrel (BAL)

With Felix Bautista out for the season after undergoing Tommy John surgery, the Orioles signed Kimbrel to be their closer. He figures to take over Bautista’s role as the primary closer, while Yennier Cano will likely see some save chances as well.

Warming upYennier Cano

Kenley Jansen (BOS)

Despite being in the middle of some trade rumors this offseason, it appears Jansen will remain with Boston. He recorded 29 saves last season but did struggle at times, posting a 3.63 ERA on the year.

Warming up: Chris Martin

Clay Holmes (NYY)

Despite some inconsistency last season, Holmes was able to avoid arbitration with the Yankees and figures to remain in his closer role again this year. He has combined to record 44 saves across the past two seasons. It is possible he has a short leash if he shows any signs of struggling early.

Warming up: Jonathan Loaisiga, Tommy Kahnle

Pete Fairbanks (TB)

It was a strong season last year for Fairbanks, recording 25 saves to go along with a 2.58 ERA across 45 1/3 innings. He should remain in a similar role in the Rays bullpen once again this season.

Warming up: Jason Adam, Phil Maton

Jordan Romano (TOR)

Having recorded 36 saves in back-to-back seasons, Romano remains one of the top closers in the majors from a real life standpoint and fantasy standpoint. He should be one of the first closers selected in fantasy drafts once again this season.

Warming up: Erik Swanson

American League Central

White Sox – Committee

It was initially thought that John Brebbia would be the favorite to close games for the White Sox but he strained his calf and is expected to miss the next few weeks.

Jesse Chavez and Bryan Shaw could also close games this season.

One other reliever to keep an eye on is Prelander Berroa, who the White Sox acquired from the Mariners when they traded Gregory Santos.

Emmanuel Clase (CLE)

Having recorded 86 saves across the past two seasons, Clase remains one of the top closers in the majors. He should be one of the first closers selected in fantasy drafts this season.

Warming up: Scott Barlow

Alex Lange (DET)

It was a bit of an up-and-down season for Lange last year, who finished with 26 saves while recording a 3.68 ERA and 1.33 WHIP across 66 innings. He should remain the Tigers’ closer this season but it is possible he gets removed if he shows any signs of struggling early on.

Warming up: Jason Foley

Royals – Committee

Back in December, Royals manager Matt Quatraro told reporters the team doesn’t currently have one closer on its roster.

James McArthur finished the 2023 season as the closer for Kansas City and currently figures to get the first shot to close games but it is a fluid situation that’ll be worth monitoring early in the season.

Jhoan Duran (MIN)

In his first full season as a closer last year, Duran recorded 27 saves with a 2.45 ERA across 62 1/3 innings. He is expected to remain in a similar role once again this season.

Warming up: Griffin Jax

American League West

Josh Hader (HOU)

One of the bigger signings in free agency this offseason was the Astros landing Hader on a five-year deal. It has already been announced that he’ll be the primary closer this season ahead of Ryan Pressly. There could be some risk with Hader if Pressly eats into his workload but Hader should see plenty of opportunities.

Warming up: Ryan Pressly

Carlos Estevez (LAA)

While he finished the season with 31 saves, it was a bit of a shaky second half of the season last year for Estevez. Despite his late season struggles, Estevez is expected to remain in his closer role to open this season but it is possible his leash isn’t super long.

Warming up: Luis Garcia

Athletics – Committee

Mason Miller is expected to move from the starting rotation to the bullpen for the Athletics. He seems to be the best bet to get the first shot at save chances.

Andres Munoz (SEA)

After the Mariners traded Paul Sewald last year at the trade deadline, Munoz went through some struggles after taking over the full-time closer role. Despite those struggles, he now has a full offseason to prepare and is worth targeting in the middle rounds of fantasy drafts.

Warming up: Matt Brash, Gregory Santos

Jose Leclerc (TEX)

It is worth noting that Rangers manager Bruce Bochy mentioned earlier in February that “there is no pecking order” between Leclerc and the rest of the bullpen. That is worth monitoring, but he is expected to get the first shot at save chances.

Warming up: David Robertson

National League East

Raisel Iglesias (ATL)

In his first full season with the Braves, Iglesias recorded 33 saves while posting a 2.75 ERA across 55 2/3 innings. He should see plenty of save chances once again this season.

Warming up: Reynaldo Lopez, A.J. Minter

Tanner Scott (MIA)

Scott was able to win his arbitration case against the Marlins this offseason after posting a 2.31 ERA with 12 saves across 78 innings pitched last season. He should see plenty of save chances on a Miami team that figures to be in a lot of close games.

Warming up: A.J. Puk

Edwin Diaz (NYM)

Making his return from a torn right patellar tendon, Diaz remains on track to be fully healthy entering Opening Day. There is always reason to have some concern with any pitcher coming off this injury but he should return to his dominant form if he can stay healthy.

Warming up: Brooks Raley

Jose Alvarado (PHI)

With Kimbrel in Baltimore, Alvarado figures to step into the closer role this season for the Phillies. He recorded 10 saves last year, while posting a sparkling 1.74 ERA across 41 1/3 innings pitched.

Warming up: Gregory Soto

Kyle Finnegan (WSH)

Finnegan was able to avoid arbitration with the Nationals this offseason. He struggled at times last year but still managed to record 28 saves with a 3.76 ERA across 69 1/3 innings.

Warming up: Hunter Harvey

National League Central

Adbert Alzolay (CHC)

One of the under the radar free agent signings this offseason was the Cubs bringing in Hector Neris. Alzolay figures to remain in his closer role heading into Opening Day but it is possible Neris takes some of those save chances from him.

Warming up: Hector Neris

Alexis Diaz (CIN)

One of the best and most consistent closers in the MLB last season, Diaz will be looking to pick up where he left off last season. With the Reds also showing signs of improvement as a team, Diaz could be an intriguing value in drafts this season.

Warming up: Lucas Sims

Devin Williams (MIL)

With the Brewers trading Corbin Burnes this offseason, there were some trade rumors that involved Williams but it appears he’ll remain with Milwaukee to open the season. He could be a potential trade candidate at the deadline if Milwaukee is struggling as a team.

Warming up: Joel Payamps

David Bednar (PIT)

The Pirates did sign Aroldis Chapman this offseason but Bednar is expected to remain in his primary closer role. It is possible Chapman eats into his workload a little more than anyone else did for the Pirates in recent seasons.

Warming up: Aroldis Chapman

Ryan Helsley (STL)

Helsley was able to avoid arbitration with the Cardinals this offseason. He saw just 19 save chances last season, recording 14 of them into saves while posting a 2.45 ERA across 36 2/3 innings. He’ll hope to see some more opportunities this season.

Warming up: Giovanny Gallegos, Keynan Middleton

National League West

Paul Sewald (ARI)

After the Diamondbacks traded for Sewald at the deadline last season, he became a huge part of their success over the second half of the season and in the playoffs on their run to the World Series. He should remain in the same role this year in what will be his first full season in Arizona.

Warming up: Kevin Ginkel

Rockies – Committee

The bullpen was a complete mess for Colorado last season. It was Justin Lawrence who led the Rockies bullpen in saves last season among players who ended the year on the team after Pierce Johnson was dealt to Atlanta. Lawrence is likely the best bet to see the first shot at save chances for the Rockies.

Evan Phillips (LAD)

Dodgers manager Dave Roberts told reporter that Phillips will receive the majority of the save chances this season. He recorded 24 saves last season, while posting a 2.05 ERA across 61 1/3 innings.

Warming up: Joe Kelly, Brusdar Graterol

Padres – Closer battle

As of the first week of February, Padres manager Mike Shildt said he hadn’t chosen his closer for the 2024 season. Robert Suarez, Yuki Matsui and Wandy Peralta are among the relievers who will be competing for the closer role in the Padres bullpen.

Camilo Doval (SF)

Coming off a dominant season, Doval recorded 39 saves last year with a 2.93 ERA across 67 2/3 innings. He figures to remain a top 3-5 closer for fantasy managers this season in the same role.

Warming up: Tyler Rogers

More Fantasy Baseball Draft Advice


Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Google Podcasts | SoundCloud | iHeartRadio

More Articles

Video: Juan Soto Signs With Mets | Reactions & Predictions (2025 Fantasy Baseball)

Video: Juan Soto Signs With Mets | Reactions & Predictions (2025 Fantasy Baseball)

fp-headshot by FantasyPros Staff | 1 min read
Video: 10 Fantasy Baseball Rookies to Draft (2025)

Video: 10 Fantasy Baseball Rookies to Draft (2025)

fp-headshot by FantasyPros Staff | 1 min read
Fantasy Baseball Watchlist: Tony Gonsolin, Kyle Wright, Jordan Hicks

Fantasy Baseball Watchlist: Tony Gonsolin, Kyle Wright, Jordan Hicks

fp-headshot by Ben Rosener | 4 min read
Video: 2025 Fantasy Baseball Rankings (Dynasty Risers & Fallers)

Video: 2025 Fantasy Baseball Rankings (Dynasty Risers & Fallers)

fp-headshot by FantasyPros Staff | 1 min read

About Author

Hide

Current Article

5 min read

Video: Juan Soto Signs With Mets | Reactions & Predictions (2025 Fantasy Baseball)

Next Up - Video: Juan Soto Signs With Mets | Reactions & Predictions (2025 Fantasy Baseball)

Next Article