Skip Navigation to Main Content

2025 NFL Draft Round 1 Winners & Losers (Fantasy Football)

2025 NFL Draft Round 1 Winners & Losers (Fantasy Football)

Welcome to my fantasy football breakdown of the 2025 NFL Draft’s first round, where dreams were made for 32 bright-eyed rookies, and the chessboard of professional football is reset with fresh, ambitious talent.

In this featured piece recapping round one, I will delve into the immediate impact of the newly minted rookies and how their arrival alters the dynamics for veteran players within their teams.

From soaring fantasy stocks of rookies poised to make a significant mark in their debut seasons to veterans who might find their positions threatened or bolstered by these young additions, we’ll explore who emerged as the winners and losers of this pivotal day in the NFL calendar.

Join me as we break down the changing landscapes of NFL squads and assess the potential shifts in strategy and performance prompted by this year’s Day 1 selections. I also broke down the winners and losers of Day 2.

Dynasty Draft Kit 2025

2025 NFL Draft Winners & Losers

2025 NFL Draft Round 1 Winners

Tetairoa McMillan (WR – CAR)

Dave Canales just got his Mike Evans.

I think this is a great spot for the former Arizona receiver. I wanted Tetairoa McMillan to go somewhere to be a true alpha. And I think the Panthers’ offense is exactly that.

Xavier Legette is coming off a disappointing rookie season and Jalen Coker (albeit impressive as a rookie) was a former undrafted free agent.

Opportunities should be there for McMillan in Carolina. Bryce Young, despite his many flaws, has shown an ability to support fantasy production with his wide receivers.

I also love that Adam Thielen is still on the roster, to help mentor these young wideouts, so they can grow together with their third-year quarterback.

McMillan earned top-10 draft capital with above-average size. Don’t overthink it.

Travis Hunter (WR – JAX)

One of the splashiest moves from Day 1 hit early, with the Jacksonville Jaguars trading up to No. 2 overall to select Travis Hunter.

The Jags got pick No. 2, plus a fourth- and sixth-round pick. The Browns received No. 5, No. 36, No. 126 and the Jaguars’ 2026 first-round pick.

We shall see how Jacksonville decides to deploy Hunter. The expectation is that he will primarily play offense while moonlighting on defense. However, I imagine an offensive head coach didn’t send his first pick next year to play a guy more on defense.

With Trevor Lawrence as his quarterback, Hunter is a winner. That wouldn’t have been the case in Cleveland. In fact, among the teams with top-five picks, Jacksonville was one of the best. The former Colorado standout might not be the true No. 1 WR, though, which is where this projection gets somewhat murky.

Brian Thomas Jr. established himself as the No. 1 WR last season, and all offseason, it has been overwhelming praise for the Jaguars’ offense running through Thomas.

The Jaguars also really need a cornerback on the perimeter. So, he is going to play both ways. How that works out remains to be seen, given that it’s never been done before. But downgrading Thomas substantially because they traded up for Hunter isn’t something I will do. Thomas earned targets at the college level with Malik Nabers on the roster.

Keep in mind that the Jaguars rank sixth in vacated targets (and seventh in air yards) entering the 2025 season. There’s more than enough to go around (except for Gabe Davis) and concentrate the offense on Thomas/Hunter. Just don’t hold out hope for Brenton Strange or Parker Washington to smash in 2025.

Ashton Jeanty (RB – LV)

The Raiders’ landing spot is solid for Ashton Jeanty. Las Vegas has an underrated offensive line and Geno Smith is, at worst, an average quarterback. More importantly, Jeanty is going to see all the volume he can handle. He will get all the touches he needs to score fantasy points.

I don’t think the offensive line has many glaring holes, although there is a potential depth need at the guard spot. Jordan Meredith is in the final year of his contract (restricted free agent). Cody Whitehair is a free agent. Las Vegas also needs to make sure it gets left tackle Kolton Miller extended ASAP.

Ashton Jeanty‘s average draft position (ADP) in 2025 will likely be late in the first round. Based on the proposition of talent/opportunity, it’s not a bad bet to make on the uber-talented rookie running back from Boise State.

Jerry Jeudy (WR – CLE)

Jerry Jeudy might have dodged a bullet on Draft Night. Travis Hunter was expected to join the Cleveland Browns as a wide receiver, but now it appears Jeudy is dialed in as the No. 1 WR for the Dawg Pound.

There are worse situations than 20+ targets per game from Joe Flacco/Kenny Pickett. According to 4for4.com’s vacated air yards and targets tracker, no team has more available targets than the Browns entering 2025. Cedric Tillman, we have life.

We shall see what the Browns do at quarterback on Day 2 of the NFL Draft.

Jaylen Warren (RB – PIT)

The Steelers didn’t take a running back in the first round, and they don’t have a draft pick in round two. Sure, they will add another back in the third round or on Day 3, but it’s clear that three-down workhorse Jaylen Warren is on the table.

Omarion Hampton (RB – LAC)

The Chargers drafted Omarion Hampton 22nd overall to be their future bell-cow back. I could see Hampton and Najee Harris splitting work to some extent in 2025, but we know which running back will be spearheading this team at the end of the season and in 2026. In my estimation, this is an excellent landing spot for Hampton. The Chargers want to be a run-heavy offense. They have a very good offensive line and an elite passer at quarterback.

Keep in mind that Harris is only on a one-year deal. Don’t overthink the first-round draft capital for Hampton. Even if it might be annoying at times during the start of the 2025 season, drafting Hampton should pay off in the long run.

Jaxson Dart (QB – NYG)

Jaxson Dart was the second quarterback off the board, not Shedeur Sanders. The Giants traded back up to select Dart, jumping the Los Angeles Rams. As the only other signal-caller not named Cam Ward selected in round one, Dart will have a chance to develop in New York behind Russell Wilson/Jameis Winston. All things considered, the 2025 NFL Draft was a solid run out for the Ole Miss passer.

If the veterans struggle, Dart might get a chance to play in the second half of the season. Going to Dart can be the final trump card Brian Daboll and Joe Schoen can pull to save their jobs if things start going south for Wilson.

Malik Nabers‘ value also has a chance to increase substantially with a trio of potential quarterback upgrades from last season.

Colston Loveland (TE – CHI)

Is Chicago the best spot for the 2025 season? Probably not. It’s a crowded offense with three established pass-catchers on the roster. But for what it’s worth, tight end Cole Kmet has an out in his contract in 2026.

So, if we are playing the long game (which is dynasty), this could end up being a great spot for Colston Loveland, attached to Caleb Williams and Ben Johnson over the long haul.

I think we might get an overreaction to the Year 1 landing spot — too many mouths to feed — without looking at the big outlook with Loveland. He may not light it up in Year 1, but he could have a monster Trey McBride-like Year 2 leap based on the current optics.

Loveland’s not a true “winner” because we didn’t get a smash Year 1 spot, but I am pretty confident in his long-term outlook with the Bears.

And for what it’s worth, Loveland’s short-term spot might not even be that bad. The Bears rank ninth in vacated target share, per 4for4, after losing Keenan Allen.

QBs With Upgraded Personnel

Trevor Lawrence (QB – JAX)

Getting Trevor Lawrence another key weapon in Travis Hunter is going to help him tremendously.

Pairing both Hunter and second-year receiver Brian Thomas Jr. is going to make this passing game dangerous in 2024 under new head coach Liam Coen.

Drake Maye (QB – NE)

More protection for Drake Maye. Whether Will Campbell is the best long-term option at left tackle remains to be seen, but it’s an upgrade on the Patriots’ offensive line regardless of where he settles.

Justin Fields (QB – NYJ)

The Jets got my highest-ranked tackle in Armand Membou, who can naturally fit on the right side upfront for Gang Green.

Bryce Young (WR – CAR)

Tetairoa McMillan from Arizona gives Bryce Young a massive target to throw to.

Dak Prescott (QB – DAL)

Alabama’s Tyler Booker is a quality starting guard. Probably would have preferred another wide receiver, but I digress. Will Dallas ever draft a running back? Stay tuned.

Jordan Love (QB – GB)

Adding Matthew Golden to the mix will help Jordan Love get back on track after an up-and-down, injury-plagued 2024 season.

Sam Darnold (QB – SEA)

Seattle badly needed interior offensive line help. And they got it with Grey Zabel.

J.J. McCarthy (QB – MIN)

More protection upfront with Ohio State’s Donovan Jackson. Watch out for this offensive line to bully defenses. Stock is up for both Aaron Jones and Jordan Mason.

Jayden Daniels (QB – WSH)

Washington added Oregon offensive lineman Josh Conerly, who can kick inside with the injury to Sam Cosmi.

Patrick Mahomes (QB – KC)

When healthy, Josh Simmons could end up being the best tackle in this draft class. Without the immediate need for him to start right away, this was a perfect selection for Kansas City at 32 to add more long-term protection upfront for Patrick Mahomes.

Mason Rudolph (QB – PIT)

As of the conclusion of Day 1, Mason Rudolph is the Steelers’ No. 1 QB. That’s a win. Oh, paging, Mr. Aaron Rodgers

RBs who didn’t get Nuked by a Rookie RB

FantasyPros Discord

2025 NFL Draft Round 1 Losers

Matthew Golden (WR – GB)

The Packers were always going to add a wide receiver at some point.

Makes sense, given the injury to Christian Watson (contract year) and Romeo Doubs entering the last year of his rookie contract after dealing with a flurry of concussions in 2024.

They took Matthew Golden in the first round. But Golden’s profile is hardly that of a true alpha, which means he will just be thrust into the wide receiver committee in Green Bay.

This team doesn’t want a true No. 1 WR, which is probably why they felt Golden was a good fit. I think he’s going to end up as a real “better-life” fit for the Packers, than one for fantasy football.

Golden will have his fair share of spiked weeks, but he still might not lead the Packers in routes run. I don’t believe the consistent target share will ever be apparent unless more injuries hit the Packers’ wide receiver room.

Golden also dampens the outlooks of Dontayvion Wicks/Romeo Doubs, as that is where we can see the most overlap in on-field playing time.

Emeka Egbuka (WR – TB)

Well, if there’s anyone who knows about target competition, it’s Emeka Egbuka. The landing spot for 2025 isn’t great, given Egbuka will have to work his way up the depth chart.

But Mike Evans and Chris Godwin probably aren’t reliable enough to bank on staying healthy all year. Godwin is coming off a season-ending injury, although the Bucs’ front office made it clear that the Egbuka selection had nothing to do with Godwin’s injury.

They simply went best player available on offense with the 19th overall pick.

Jalen McMillan showed out in the second half of last season, but more competition for him is also concerning. He has also dealt with injuries in the last two football seasons. It was tough enough when the team re-signed Godwin, but drafting Egbuka makes McMillan’s path to fantasy relevance much tougher.

Both of these guys are good future bets to make, and I think that’s a reason to remain bullish in dynasty. As for redraft, we should be a bit more bearish. Although for best ball formats that reward more points scored in the latter portion of the year, there’s a lot of upside for both McMillan and Egbuka if they get into the starting lineup.

I would say that long-term, Egbuka’s slot ability mirrors that of Godwin’s career archetype. Factor in first-round draft capital, and I prefer Egbuka over McMillan in dynasty.

 

Tyler Warren (TE – IND)

Speaking of potential bad landing spots. I’d argue that Tyler Warren got the worst spot between the two top tight ends in this class. There is a ton of talented pass-catchers on the Colts’ depth chart, but also a depleted offensive line and serious question marks at quarterback, both short and long-term.

Yes, Warren’s path to starting tight end reps is clear (third-highest vacated tight end target share), but what does that mean in a 2025 Colts offense?

If it’s closely ranked between Warren and Loveland in rookie drafts, I’m firmly on the Loveland side.

Najee Harris (RB – LAC)

The Chargers drafted Omarion Hampton 22nd overall to be their future bell cow. Najee Harris is on a one-year deal. Fantasy football doesn’t have to be hard.

Xavier Legette (WR – CAR)

It’s never a good look for a first-round wide receiver after a disappointing season to see his team immediately draft another wideout in round one. I was already pretty firm on my stance for Jalen Coker over Xavier Legette heading into 2025, so adding McMillan is a real bad sign.

Raheem Mostert (RB – LV)

Raheem Mostert never stood a chance.

Gabe Davis (WR – JAX)

We knew it was over when Liam Coen listed off the entire receiving corps behind Brian Thomas Jr. and “conveniently” forgot to mention Gabe Davis’ name. It’s over.

dynasty rookie mock draft simulator


Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Google Podcasts | Stitcher | SoundCloud | iHeartRadio

More Articles

Dynasty Rookies Experts Draft: Wide Receivers (Fantasy Football)

Dynasty Rookies Experts Draft: Wide Receivers (Fantasy Football)

fp-headshot by FantasyPros Staff | 2 min read
Fantasy Football TEs: Evan Engram, Brenton Strange, Tyler Warren

Fantasy Football TEs: Evan Engram, Brenton Strange, Tyler Warren

fp-headshot by FantasyPros Staff | 2 min read
3 Draft Picks to Avoid (2025 Fantasy Football)

3 Draft Picks to Avoid (2025 Fantasy Football)

fp-headshot by FantasyPros Staff | 2 min read
22 Fantasy Football Breakout Candidates (2025)

22 Fantasy Football Breakout Candidates (2025)

fp-headshot by FantasyPros Staff | 9 min read

About Author