Dissenting Opinions: Baseball Rankings

Mick Ciallela (Fantrax) vs Jake Ciely (The Athletic)

Create a Cheat Sheet
Mock Draft

Mick Ciallela likes him more

change
Mick Ciallela versus Jake Ciely Rankings
Rank Player Expert Diff.
6 Corbin Carroll (ARI - CF,RF) 30 +24
19 Cal Raleigh (SEA - C,DH) 33 +14
23 Jazz Chisholm Jr. (NYY - 2B,3B) 35 +12
29 Yordan Alvarez (HOU - LF,DH) 41 +12
31 Matt Olson (ATL - 1B) 44 +13
34 Rafael Devers (SF - 1B,DH) 47 +13
49 Roman Anthony (BOS - LF,CF,RF) 69 +20
58 Cody Bellinger (NYY - LF,CF,RF) 70 +12
62 William Contreras (MIL - C,DH) 83 +21
66 Blake Snell (LAD - SP) 82 +16
72 Kyle Bradish (BAL - SP) 94 +22
96 Tyler Glasnow (LAD - SP) 120 +24
107 Brandon Woodruff (MIL - SP) 123 +16
108 Nathan Eovaldi (TEX - SP) 132 +24
109 Jordan Westburg (BAL - 2B,3B) 260 +151
110 Luis Castillo (SEA - SP) 134 +24
114 Trey Yesavage (TOR - SP) 148 +34
115 Will Smith (LAD - C) 141 +26
117 Sandy Alcantara (MIA - SP) 162 +45
118 Drake Baldwin (ATL - C) 163 +45
119 Agustin Ramirez (MIA - C,DH) 169 +50
121 Michael King (SD - SP) 137 +16
126 Jacob Misiorowski (MIL - SP) 147 +21
129 Cam Schlittler (NYY - SP) 193 +64
131 Shane Bieber (TOR - SP) 217 +86
134 Nick Lodolo (CIN - SP) 156 +22
135 Robbie Ray (SF - SP) 166 +31
138 Ryan Pepiot (TB - SP) 151 +13
140 Ranger Suarez (BOS - SP) 168 +28
141 Gavin Williams (CLE - SP) 173 +32
145 MacKenzie Gore (TEX - SP) 159 +14
146 Trevor Rogers (BAL - SP) 180 +34
148 Bubba Chandler (PIT - SP) 198 +50
150 Tanner Bibee (CLE - SP) 177 +27
152 Shota Imanaga (CHC - SP) 202 +50
156 Drew Rasmussen (TB - SP) 186 +30
160 Carlos Rodon (NYY - SP) 201 +41
162 Jack Flaherty (DET - SP) 187 +25
164 Carlos Estevez (KC - RP) 224 +60
167 Edward Cabrera (CHC - SP) 227 +60
172 Cade Horton (CHC - SP) 276 +104
173 Aaron Nola (PHI - SP) 212 +39
176 Matthew Boyd (CHC - SP) 225 +49
180 Zac Gallen (ARI - SP) 222 +42
181 Merrill Kelly (ARI - SP) 237 +56
182 Jeff Hoffman (TOR - RP) 205 +23
186 Shane Baz (BAL - SP) 229 +43
187 Pete Fairbanks (MIA - RP) 231 +44
189 Shane McClanahan (TB - SP) 245 +56
192 Andrew Abbott (CIN - SP) 251 +59
195 Trevor Megill (MIL - RP) 257 +62
197 Daniel Palencia (CHC - RP) 232 +35
200 Connelly Early (BOS - SP) 319 +119
201 Kris Bubic (KC - SP) 264 +63
209 Emilio Pagan (CIN - RP) 248 +39
212 Mark Vientos (NYM - 3B,DH) 246 +34
213 Kenley Jansen (DET - RP) 274 +61
216 Bryce Miller (SEA - SP) 278 +62
224 Joe Musgrove (SD - SP) 258 +34
225 Dennis Santana (PIT - RP) 298 +73
226 Jasson Dominguez (NYY - LF,CF) 294 +68
229 Casey Mize (DET - SP) 290 +61
232 Shane Smith (CWS - SP) 285 +53
235 Hurston Waldrep (ATL - SP) IL60 541 +306
238 Noah Cameron (KC - SP) 338 +100
241 Gerrit Cole (NYY - SP) 287 +46
244 Ryne Nelson (ARI - SP,RP) 323 +79
245 Roki Sasaki (LAD - SP) 317 +72
250 Jose Soriano (LAA - SP) 270 +20
259 Logan Henderson (MIL - SP) 309 +50
260 David Peterson (NYM - SP) 307 +47
262 Abner Uribe (MIL - RP) 283 +21
263 Matt Shaw (CHC - 3B) 304 +41
267 Quinn Priester (MIL - SP,RP) 328 +61
268 Jack Leiter (TEX - SP) 321 +53
271 Sean Manaea (NYM - SP,RP) 314 +43
277 Kodai Senga (NYM - SP) 370 +93
278 Grayson Rodriguez (LAA - SP) IL10 297 +19
279 Robert Suarez (ATL - RP) 342 +63
280 Griffin Jax (TB - RP) 302 +22
281 Brady Singer (CIN - SP) 311 +30
282 Yusei Kikuchi (LAA - SP) 300 +18
288 Clay Holmes (NYM - SP) 361 +73
289 Michael Wacha (KC - SP) 359 +70
290 Mitch Keller (PIT - SP) 331 +41
291 Brandon Pfaadt (ARI - SP) 353 +62
292 Brayan Bello (BOS - SP) 381 +89
293 Parker Messick (CLE - SP) 390 +97
295 Zach Eflin (BAL - SP) 393 +98
296 Ryan Weathers (NYY - SP) 346 +50
297 Edwin Uceta (TB - RP) 347 +50
298 Reid Detmers (LAA - RP) 369 +71
300 Nick Castellanos (SD - RF) 326 +26

Jake Ciely likes him more

change
Jake Ciely versus Mick Ciallela Rankings
Rank Player Expert Diff.
15 Cristopher Sanchez (PHI - SP) 27 +12
16 Logan Gilbert (SEA - SP) 38 +22
20 Chris Sale (ATL - SP) 39 +19
21 Bryan Woo (SEA - SP) 41 +20
22 Hunter Brown (HOU - SP) 37 +15
23 Pete Crow-Armstrong (CHC - CF) 35 +12
26 Logan Webb (SF - SP) 40 +14
32 Hunter Greene (CIN - SP) 44 +12
36 Mason Miller (SD - RP) 68 +32
49 Edwin Diaz (LAD - RP) 82 +33
61 Byron Buxton (MIN - CF) 79 +18
80 Cade Smith (CLE - RP) 105 +25
81 Yandy Diaz (TB - 1B,DH) 95 +14
87 Trevor Story (BOS - SS) 111 +24
90 Willy Adames (SF - SS) 102 +12
95 Luke Keaschall (MIN - 2B) 122 +27
100 Josh Hader (HOU - RP) 123 +23
104 Andy Pages (LAD - LF,CF,RF) 127 +23
107 Taylor Ward (BAL - LF) 130 +23
108 Jo Adell (LAA - CF,RF) 120 +12
109 David Bednar (NYY - RP) 125 +16
111 Matt Chapman (SF - 3B) 128 +17
114 Noelvi Marte (CIN - 3B,RF) 170 +56
116 Aroldis Chapman (BOS - RP) 133 +17
117 Devin Williams (NYM - RP) 159 +42
118 Jacob Wilson (ATH - SS) 136 +18
119 Lawrence Butler (ATH - CF,RF) 144 +25
122 Steven Kwan (CLE - LF) 149 +27
124 Dansby Swanson (CHC - SS) 155 +31
125 Ezequiel Tovar (COL - SS) 175 +50
127 Luis Robert Jr. (NYM - CF) 142 +15
128 Emmet Sheehan (LAD - SP) 143 +15
129 Willson Contreras (BOS - 1B) 154 +25
130 Ian Happ (CHC - LF) 153 +23
131 Ceddanne Rafaela (BOS - 2B,CF) 151 +20
133 Bryan Reynolds (PIT - LF,CF,RF,DH) 157 +24
135 Ivan Herrera (STL - C,DH) 168 +33
136 Spencer Torkelson (DET - 1B) 158 +22
139 Brandon Lowe (PIT - 2B) 165 +26
140 Xavier Edwards (MIA - 2B,SS) 163 +23
142 Alec Burleson (STL - 1B,LF,RF,DH) 177 +35
143 Jonathan Aranda (TB - 1B) 171 +28
146 Brenton Doyle (COL - CF) 183 +37
149 Munetaka Murakami (CWS - 1B,3B) 242 +93
152 Gleyber Torres (DET - 2B) 193 +41
153 Heliot Ramos (SF - LF,CF,RF) 190 +37
154 Christian Walker (HOU - 1B) 169 +15
155 Bryson Stott (PHI - 2B,SS) 196 +41
157 Royce Lewis (MIN - 3B) 191 +34
158 Dylan Crews (WSH - CF,RF) 174 +16
160 Marcus Semien (NYM - 2B) 184 +24
164 Chandler Simpson (TB - LF,CF) 206 +42
165 Xander Bogaerts (SD - SS) 218 +53
167 Luis Garcia (WSH - 2B) 205 +38
170 Wilyer Abreu (BOS - LF,CF,RF) 211 +41
172 Mike Trout (LAA - CF,RF,DH) 204 +32
174 Isaac Paredes (HOU - 3B) 199 +25
175 Masyn Winn (STL - SS) 203 +28
176 Alejandro Kirk (TOR - C) 188 +12
178 Kyle Manzardo (CLE - 1B,DH) 207 +29
181 Alec Bohm (PHI - 1B,3B) 221 +40
182 Daylen Lile (WSH - LF,RF) 208 +26
183 Jorge Polanco (NYM - 2B,3B,DH) 210 +27
185 Kerry Carpenter (DET - LF,RF,DH) 215 +30
188 Otto Lopez (MIA - 2B,SS) 236 +48
190 Addison Barger (TOR - 3B,LF,RF) 202 +12
191 Sal Stewart (CIN - 1B) 219 +28
192 Daulton Varsho (TOR - LF,CF) 214 +22
194 Kazuma Okamoto (TOR - 1B,3B) 266 +72
195 Adolis Garcia (PHI - RF) 237 +42
196 Matt McLain (CIN - 2B) 217 +21
197 Andrew Vaughn (MIL - 1B) 220 +23
199 Jake Burger (TEX - 1B) 247 +48
200 Luis Arraez (SF - 1B,2B,DH) 252 +52
203 Carlos Correa (HOU - 3B,SS) 243 +40
204 Caleb Durbin (BOS - 2B,3B) 253 +49
206 Mickey Moniak (COL - LF,CF,RF) 254 +48
207 Brendan Donovan (SEA - 2B,SS,LF) 227 +20
208 Sal Frelick (MIL - LF,CF,RF) 222 +14
209 Gabriel Moreno (ARI - C) 230 +21
210 Nolan Schanuel (LAA - 1B) 249 +39
211 Ramon Laureano (SD - LF,CF,RF) 240 +29
213 Jordan Beck (COL - LF,RF) 248 +35
214 Miguel Vargas (CWS - 1B,3B) 276 +62
215 Trent Grisham (NYY - CF) 234 +19
216 Max Muncy (LAD - 3B) 269 +53
219 Jac Caglianone (KC - 1B,RF) 239 +20
220 Marcell Ozuna (PIT - DH) 257 +37
223 Brett Baty (NYM - 2B,3B) 256 +33
230 Josh Lowe (LAA - LF,CF,RF) 255 +25
233 Colton Cowser (BAL - LF,CF,RF) 261 +28
235 Josh Bell (MIN - 1B,DH) 284 +49
236 J.T. Realmuto (PHI - C) 270 +34
238 Jung Hoo Lee (SF - CF) 274 +36
239 Francisco Alvarez (NYM - C) 251 +12
241 Tommy Edman (LAD - 2B,3B,CF) 264 +23
243 Jeff McNeil (ATH - 2B,LF,CF,RF) 286 +43
247 Colt Keith (DET - 1B,2B,3B,DH) 294 +47
255 Anthony Volpe (NYY - SS) 287 +32
261 Chase DeLauter (CLE - CF,RF) 275 +14
266 JJ Wetherholt (STL - 2B,3B,SS) NRI 285 +19
269 Dillon Dingler (DET - C) 283 +14
282 Carter Jensen (KC - C) 299 +17