Dissenting Opinions: Baseball Rankings
Mick Ciallela (Fantrax) vs Jake Ciely (The Athletic)
Mick Ciallela likes him more
| Rank | Player | Expert | Diff. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9 | Corbin Carroll (ARI - CF,RF) | 23 | +14 |
| 21 | Yordan Alvarez (HOU - LF,DH) | 34 | +13 |
| 35 | Wyatt Langford (TEX - LF,CF) | 47 | +12 |
| 45 | Jesus Luzardo (PHI - SP) | 80 | +35 |
| 47 | Jarren Duran (BOS - LF,CF) | 62 | +15 |
| 48 | Maikel Garcia (KC - 2B,3B,SS,OF) | 61 | +13 |
| 54 | Dylan Cease (TOR - SP) | 70 | +16 |
| 56 | George Springer (TOR - LF,CF,RF,DH) IL10 | 77 | +21 |
| 67 | Randy Arozarena (SEA - LF,CF) | 82 | +15 |
| 71 | Oneil Cruz (PIT - CF) | 91 | +20 |
| 74 | Devin Williams (NYM - RP) | 94 | +20 |
| 76 | Luis Robert Jr. (NYM - CF) | 121 | +45 |
| 81 | Nico Hoerner (CHC - 2B) | 100 | +19 |
| 82 | Teoscar Hernandez (LAD - LF,RF) | 99 | +17 |
| 84 | Ben Rice (NYY - C,1B,DH) | 103 | +19 |
| 86 | Kevin Gausman (TOR - SP) | 102 | +16 |
| 88 | Yandy Diaz (TB - 1B,DH) | 122 | +34 |
| 92 | Zack Wheeler (PHI - SP) IL15 | 139 | +47 |
| 100 | Emmet Sheehan (LAD - SP) | 118 | +18 |
| 101 | Nathan Eovaldi (TEX - SP) | 120 | +19 |
| 102 | Salvador Perez (KC - C,1B,DH) | 163 | +61 |
| 103 | Brandon Woodruff (MIL - SP) | 115 | +12 |
| 108 | Dansby Swanson (CHC - SS) | 127 | +19 |
| 112 | Ceddanne Rafaela (BOS - 2B,CF) | 135 | +23 |
| 114 | Brenton Doyle (COL - CF) | 153 | +39 |
| 115 | Luis Castillo (SEA - SP) | 140 | +25 |
| 117 | Michael Busch (CHC - 1B) | 129 | +12 |
| 123 | Gavin Williams (CLE - SP) | 158 | +35 |
| 124 | Daniel Palencia (CHC - RP) IL15 | 150 | +26 |
| 127 | MacKenzie Gore (TEX - SP) | 160 | +33 |
| 128 | Ezequiel Tovar (COL - SS) | 167 | +39 |
| 133 | Ian Happ (CHC - LF) | 152 | +19 |
| 134 | Shota Imanaga (CHC - SP) | 165 | +31 |
| 139 | Chandler Simpson (TB - LF,CF) | 173 | +34 |
| 141 | Aaron Nola (PHI - SP) | 200 | +59 |
| 142 | Alec Burleson (STL - 1B,LF,RF,DH) | 174 | +32 |
| 146 | Bryson Stott (PHI - 2B,SS) | 185 | +39 |
| 148 | Tanner Bibee (CLE - SP) | 166 | +18 |
| 149 | Spencer Strider (ATL - SP) IL15 | 184 | +35 |
| 151 | Edward Cabrera (CHC - SP) | 183 | +32 |
| 156 | Emilio Pagan (CIN - RP) | 169 | +13 |
| 157 | Carlos Rodon (NYY - SP) IL15 | 182 | +25 |
| 158 | Jack Flaherty (DET - SP) | 175 | +17 |
| 165 | Shane Baz (BAL - SP) | 194 | +29 |
| 170 | Xander Bogaerts (SD - SS) | 196 | +26 |
| 174 | Griffin Jax (TB - RP) | 248 | +74 |
| 176 | Matthew Boyd (CHC - SP) IL15 | 204 | +28 |
| 177 | Otto Lopez (MIA - 2B,SS) | 230 | +53 |
| 178 | Zac Gallen (ARI - SP) | 210 | +32 |
| 179 | Cade Horton (CHC - SP) IL15 | 199 | +20 |
| 180 | Ryan Walker (SF - RP) | 207 | +27 |
| 185 | Abner Uribe (MIL - RP) | 226 | +41 |
| 186 | Daulton Varsho (TOR - LF,CF) DTD | 225 | +39 |
| 187 | Shane McClanahan (TB - SP) | 206 | +19 |
| 188 | Luis Garcia (WSH - 1B,2B) | 201 | +13 |
| 190 | Jordan Beck (COL - LF,RF) | 219 | +29 |
| 193 | Kris Bubic (KC - SP) | 208 | +15 |
| 195 | Andrew Abbott (CIN - SP) | 237 | +42 |
| 205 | Mickey Moniak (COL - LF,CF,RF) | 242 | +37 |
| 206 | Jack Leiter (TEX - SP) | 255 | +49 |
| 210 | Cody Ponce (TOR - SP,RP) IL60 | 285 | +75 |
| 214 | JJ Wetherholt (STL - 2B,3B,SS) | 229 | +15 |
| 216 | Merrill Kelly (ARI - SP) | 253 | +37 |
| 217 | Shane Smith (CWS - SP) MiLB | 264 | +47 |
| 219 | Carlos Estevez (KC - RP) IL15 | 231 | +12 |
| 226 | Willi Castro (COL - 2B,3B,LF,RF) DTD | 262 | +36 |
| 228 | Mike Burrows (HOU - SP,RP) | 303 | +75 |
| 229 | Justin Crawford (PHI - CF) | 282 | +53 |
| 232 | Chad Patrick (MIL - SP) | 353 | +121 |
| 235 | Casey Mize (DET - SP) | 276 | +41 |
| 237 | Kodai Senga (NYM - SP) | 263 | +26 |
| 240 | Jose Soriano (LAA - SP) | 273 | +33 |
| 241 | Ryne Nelson (ARI - SP,RP) | 260 | +19 |
| 243 | Miguel Vargas (CWS - 1B,3B) | 257 | +14 |
| 246 | Masyn Winn (STL - SS) | 258 | +12 |
| 247 | Braxton Ashcraft (PIT - SP,RP) | 272 | +25 |
| 249 | Joey Cantillo (CLE - SP,RP) | 280 | +31 |
| 251 | David Peterson (NYM - SP) | 293 | +42 |
| 253 | Clay Holmes (NYM - SP) | 309 | +56 |
| 254 | Parker Messick (CLE - SP) | 286 | +32 |
| 256 | Andres Gimenez (TOR - 2B,SS) | 277 | +21 |
| 257 | Reid Detmers (LAA - SP,RP) | 328 | +71 |
| 261 | Noah Cameron (KC - SP) | 278 | +17 |
| 266 | Yusei Kikuchi (LAA - SP) | 334 | +68 |
| 267 | Chris Bassitt (BAL - SP) | 361 | +94 |
| 268 | Reynaldo Lopez (ATL - SP) | 336 | +68 |
| 270 | Will Warren (NYY - SP) | 301 | +31 |
| 273 | Brady Singer (CIN - SP) | 333 | +60 |
| 276 | Mitch Keller (PIT - SP) | 297 | +21 |
| 277 | Brandon Pfaadt (ARI - SP) | 365 | +88 |
| 278 | Jameson Taillon (CHC - SP) | 337 | +59 |
| 281 | Bailey Ober (MIN - SP) | 335 | +54 |
| 282 | Sean Manaea (NYM - SP,RP) | 306 | +24 |
| 284 | Robert Garcia (TEX - RP) | 310 | +26 |
| 285 | Jordan Lawlar (ARI - 3B,LF) IL60 | 319 | +34 |
| 291 | Logan Henderson (MIL - SP) MiLB | 314 | +23 |
| 293 | Cade Cavalli (WSH - SP) | 348 | +55 |
| 294 | Max Meyer (MIA - SP) | 425 | +131 |
| 295 | Jacob Lopez (ATH - SP) | 369 | +74 |
| 297 | Tyler Mahle (SF - SP) | 368 | +71 |
| 298 | Grayson Rodriguez (LAA - SP) IL15 | 324 | +26 |
| 300 | Victor Scott (STL - CF) | 344 | +44 |
| 304 | Grant Taylor (CWS - SP,RP) | 343 | +39 |
| 305 | Zach Eflin (BAL - SP) IL60 | 351 | +46 |
| 306 | Zebby Matthews (MIN - SP) MiLB | 320 | +14 |
| 308 | Slade Cecconi (CLE - SP) | 443 | +135 |
| 313 | Cristian Javier (HOU - SP) IL15 | 381 | +68 |
| 315 | Matthew Liberatore (STL - SP) | 423 | +108 |
| 318 | Brayan Bello (BOS - SP) | 357 | +39 |
| 322 | Michael Wacha (KC - SP) | 360 | +38 |
| 324 | Simeon Woods Richardson (MIN - SP) | 428 | +104 |
| 325 | Jake McCarthy (COL - LF,CF,RF) | 391 | +66 |
| 331 | Taj Bradley (MIN - SP) | 432 | +101 |
| 333 | Seth Lugo (KC - SP) | 377 | +44 |
| 334 | Luis Severino (ATH - SP) | 380 | +46 |
| 335 | Justin Steele (CHC - SP) IL60 | 374 | +39 |
| 339 | Landen Roupp (SF - SP) | 492 | +153 |
| 341 | Jesus Sanchez (TOR - LF,CF,RF) | 367 | +26 |
| 342 | Justin Verlander (DET - SP) IL15 | 514 | +172 |
| 343 | Tyler O'Neill (BAL - LF,RF) IL7 | 383 | +40 |
| 350 | Taylor Rogers (MIN - RP) | 387 | +37 |
| 352 | Dustin May (STL - SP) | 421 | +69 |
| 353 | Jeffrey Springs (ATH - SP) | 433 | +80 |
| 359 | Josh Smith (TEX - 1B,2B,3B,SS,LF,RF) | 390 | +31 |
| 360 | Garrett Cleavinger (TB - RP) IL15 | 409 | +49 |
| 361 | Zack Littell (WSH - SP) | 452 | +91 |
| 362 | Clayton Beeter (WSH - RP) | 405 | +43 |
| 363 | Max Scherzer (TOR - SP) | 483 | +120 |
| 372 | Paul Sewald (ARI - RP) | 427 | +55 |
| 381 | Jeremiah Estrada (SD - RP) IL15 | 397 | +16 |
| 382 | Lane Thomas (KC - LF,CF,RF) | 417 | +35 |
| 384 | Garrett Whitlock (BOS - RP) | 415 | +31 |
| 386 | Foster Griffin (WSH - SP,RP) | 486 | +100 |
| 388 | Matt Svanson (STL - RP) | 430 | +42 |
| 391 | Eduardo Rodriguez (ARI - SP) | 469 | +78 |
| 398 | Michael McGreevy (STL - SP) | 446 | +48 |
| 399 | Rhett Lowder (CIN - SP) | 477 | +78 |
| 400 | Lourdes Gurriel Jr. (ARI - LF) IL10 | 424 | +24 |
| 403 | Didier Fuentes (ATL - SP) MiLB | 523 | +120 |
| 404 | Steven Matz (TB - SP,RP) | 509 | +105 |
| 411 | Kumar Rocker (TEX - SP) | 541 | +130 |
| 415 | Nick Martinez (TB - SP,RP) | 479 | +64 |
| 417 | Johan Oviedo (BOS - SP) IL60 | 450 | +33 |
| 419 | Michael Soroka (ARI - SP,RP) | 474 | +55 |
| 424 | Dean Kremer (BAL - SP) | 468 | +44 |
| 429 | Adrian Houser (SF - SP) | 521 | +92 |
| 433 | Cole Sands (MIN - SP,RP) | 500 | +67 |
| 434 | Luis Morales (ATH - SP) MiLB | 447 | +13 |
| 436 | Chris Martin (TEX - RP) IL15 | 472 | +36 |
| 437 | Denzel Clarke (ATH - CF) | 457 | +20 |
| 438 | Anthony Kay (CWS - SP,RP) | 522 | +84 |
| 441 | Garrett Mitchell (MIL - CF,RF) | 481 | +40 |
| 444 | Hogan Harris (ATH - RP) | 533 | +89 |
| 448 | Mark Leiter Jr. (ATH - RP) | 520 | +72 |
| 453 | Gregory Soto (PIT - RP) | 515 | +62 |
| 454 | Cole Henry (WSH - RP) IL15 | 542 | +88 |
Jake Ciely likes him more
| Rank | Player | Expert | Diff. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 19 | Cal Raleigh (SEA - C,DH) | 34 | +15 |
| 35 | Jackson Chourio (MIL - LF,CF,RF) IL10 | 63 | +28 |
| 41 | Matt Olson (ATL - 1B) | 77 | +36 |
| 45 | Rafael Devers (SF - 1B,DH) | 59 | +14 |
| 46 | Mookie Betts (LAD - SS) IL10 | 60 | +14 |
| 53 | Josh Naylor (SEA - 1B,DH) | 75 | +22 |
| 58 | Riley Greene (DET - LF,CF,RF,DH) | 78 | +20 |
| 59 | William Contreras (MIL - C,DH) | 72 | +13 |
| 64 | Cody Bellinger (NYY - LF,CF,RF) | 89 | +25 |
| 66 | Nolan McLean (NYM - SP) | 107 | +41 |
| 69 | Vinnie Pasquantino (KC - 1B,DH) | 91 | +22 |
| 71 | Geraldo Perdomo (ARI - SS) | 83 | +12 |
| 75 | Tyler Soderstrom (ATH - 1B,LF) | 96 | +21 |
| 84 | Kyle Bradish (BAL - SP) | 99 | +15 |
| 85 | Jac Caglianone (KC - 1B,RF) | 207 | +122 |
| 86 | Seiya Suzuki (CHC - LF,RF,DH) | 98 | +12 |
| 87 | Eugenio Suarez (CIN - 3B,DH) | 116 | +29 |
| 96 | Alex Bregman (CHC - 3B) | 118 | +22 |
| 98 | Willy Adames (SF - SS) | 113 | +15 |
| 101 | Sal Stewart (CIN - 1B) | 169 | +68 |
| 104 | Jacob Misiorowski (MIL - SP) | 145 | +41 |
| 105 | Will Smith (LAD - C) | 120 | +15 |
| 108 | Tyler Glasnow (LAD - SP) | 122 | +14 |
| 111 | Drake Baldwin (ATL - C,DH) | 159 | +48 |
| 114 | Kyle Stowers (MIA - LF,CF,RF) IL10 | 189 | +75 |
| 116 | Blake Snell (LAD - SP) IL15 | 129 | +13 |
| 123 | Ozzie Albies (ATL - 2B) | 162 | +39 |
| 125 | Raisel Iglesias (ATL - RP) | 144 | +19 |
| 126 | Matt Chapman (SF - 3B) | 138 | +12 |
| 130 | Matt McLain (CIN - 2B) | 152 | +22 |
| 131 | Ivan Herrera (STL - C,DH) | 160 | +29 |
| 132 | Jacob Wilson (ATH - SS) | 164 | +32 |
| 134 | Jeff Hoffman (TOR - RP) | 147 | +13 |
| 138 | Cam Schlittler (NYY - SP) | 171 | +33 |
| 142 | Munetaka Murakami (CWS - 1B,3B) | 183 | +41 |
| 143 | Steven Kwan (CLE - LF,CF) | 173 | +30 |
| 148 | Sandy Alcantara (MIA - SP) | 163 | +15 |
| 149 | Jonathan Aranda (TB - 1B) | 161 | +12 |
| 151 | Noelvi Marte (CIN - 3B,RF) MiLB | 182 | +31 |
| 155 | Josh Hader (HOU - RP) IL60 | 175 | +20 |
| 162 | Trey Yesavage (TOR - SP) IL15 | 196 | +34 |
| 164 | Brandon Lowe (PIT - 2B) | 208 | +44 |
| 170 | Adley Rutschman (BAL - C) IL10 | 199 | +29 |
| 171 | Spencer Torkelson (DET - 1B) | 198 | +27 |
| 172 | Kazuma Okamoto (TOR - 1B,3B) | 200 | +28 |
| 177 | Mike Trout (LAA - CF,RF,DH) | 202 | +25 |
| 179 | Wilyer Abreu (BOS - LF,CF,RF) | 191 | +12 |
| 180 | Christian Walker (HOU - 1B) | 209 | +29 |
| 181 | Marcus Semien (NYM - 2B) | 204 | +23 |
| 186 | Addison Barger (TOR - 3B,LF,RF) IL10 | 211 | +25 |
| 187 | Jackson Holliday (BAL - 2B,SS) IL10 | 213 | +26 |
| 189 | Royce Lewis (MIN - 3B) IL10 | 242 | +53 |
| 191 | Colson Montgomery (CWS - 3B,SS) | 269 | +78 |
| 195 | Kerry Carpenter (DET - LF,RF,DH) | 221 | +26 |
| 202 | Jorge Polanco (NYM - 2B,3B,DH) IL10 | 227 | +25 |
| 203 | Carson Benge (NYM - LF,CF,RF) | 355 | +152 |
| 205 | Isaac Paredes (HOU - 3B) DTD | 287 | +82 |
| 211 | Kevin McGonigle (DET - 3B,SS) | 231 | +20 |
| 212 | Kyle Manzardo (CLE - 1B,DH) | 274 | +62 |
| 213 | Gerrit Cole (NYY - SP) IL15 | 230 | +17 |
| 214 | Gabriel Moreno (ARI - C) IL10 | 250 | +36 |
| 221 | Carlos Correa (HOU - 3B,SS) | 264 | +43 |
| 223 | Samuel Basallo (BAL - C,DH) | 260 | +37 |
| 224 | Brendan Donovan (SEA - 2B,3B,SS,LF) DTD | 236 | +12 |
| 227 | Brett Baty (NYM - 1B,2B,3B,RF) | 289 | +62 |
| 228 | Francisco Alvarez (NYM - C) | 263 | +35 |
| 233 | Dylan Crews (WSH - CF,RF) MiLB | 265 | +32 |
| 235 | Trent Grisham (NYY - CF) | 252 | +17 |
| 238 | Marcell Ozuna (PIT - DH) | 303 | +65 |
| 239 | Carter Jensen (KC - C,DH) | 275 | +36 |
| 240 | TJ Friedl (CIN - LF,CF) | 299 | +59 |
| 246 | Josh Lowe (LAA - LF,CF,RF) | 271 | +25 |
| 247 | Nolan Schanuel (LAA - 1B) | 296 | +49 |
| 249 | Spencer Steer (CIN - 1B,LF) | 319 | +70 |
| 252 | Mark Vientos (NYM - 1B,3B,DH) | 367 | +115 |
| 254 | Chase DeLauter (CLE - CF,RF,DH) | 302 | +48 |
| 256 | Kyle Teel (CWS - C) IL10 | 283 | +27 |
| 265 | Jordan Westburg (BAL - 2B,3B) IL60 | 337 | +72 |
| 266 | Dillon Dingler (DET - C) | 292 | +26 |
| 267 | Giancarlo Stanton (NYY - LF,RF,DH) | 288 | +21 |
| 268 | Ryan O'Hearn (PIT - 1B,LF,RF,DH) | 280 | +12 |
| 269 | Shane Bieber (TOR - SP) IL60 | 301 | +32 |
| 271 | Jeff McNeil (ATH - 2B,LF,CF,RF) | 311 | +40 |
| 274 | Connelly Early (BOS - SP) | 307 | +33 |
| 279 | Matt Shaw (CHC - 3B,RF) | 356 | +77 |
| 281 | Robert Suarez (ATL - RP) | 312 | +31 |
| 283 | Austin Wells (NYY - C) | 323 | +40 |
| 284 | Mick Abel (MIN - SP) | 321 | +37 |
| 287 | Colt Keith (DET - 1B,2B,3B,DH) | 309 | +22 |
| 288 | Jasson Dominguez (NYY - LF,CF) MiLB | 414 | +126 |
| 292 | Logan O'Hoppe (LAA - C) | 316 | +24 |
| 294 | Bryce Eldridge (SF - 1B,DH) MiLB | 430 | +136 |
| 295 | Tyler Stephenson (CIN - C) | 328 | +33 |
| 296 | Brandon Marsh (PHI - LF,CF) | 320 | +24 |
| 298 | Andrew Painter (PHI - SP) | 314 | +16 |
| 299 | Brooks Lee (MIN - 2B,3B,SS) | 371 | +72 |
| 300 | Roki Sasaki (LAD - SP) | 327 | +27 |
| 302 | Hunter Greene (CIN - SP) D15 | 351 | +49 |
| 304 | Nolan Arenado (ARI - 3B) | 317 | +13 |
| 305 | Kyle Harrison (MIL - SP,RP) | 338 | +33 |
| 307 | Quinn Priester (MIL - SP,RP) IL15 | 345 | +38 |
| 308 | Anthony Volpe (NYY - SS) IL10 | 336 | +28 |
| 311 | Tommy Edman (LAD - 2B,3B,CF) IL10 | 385 | +74 |
| 312 | Evan Carter (TEX - LF,CF,RF) | 329 | +17 |
| 313 | Brandon Sproat (MIL - SP) | 377 | +64 |
| 315 | Josh Jung (TEX - 3B) | 358 | +43 |
| 317 | Cam Smith (HOU - RF) | 348 | +31 |
| 321 | J.P. Crawford (SEA - SS) | 421 | +100 |
| 322 | Chase Meidroth (CWS - 2B,3B,SS) | 365 | +43 |
| 323 | Jake Cronenworth (SD - 1B,2B,SS) | 347 | +24 |
| 325 | Lenyn Sosa (TOR - 1B,2B,DH) | 379 | +54 |
| 326 | Spencer Horwitz (PIT - 1B) | 425 | +99 |
| 327 | Coby Mayo (BAL - 1B,3B) | 387 | +60 |
| 330 | Edwin Uceta (TB - RP) IL15 | 344 | +14 |
| 331 | Nick Castellanos (SD - RF,DH) | 410 | +79 |
| 338 | Edgar Quero (CWS - C,DH) | 370 | +32 |
| 339 | Owen Caissie (MIA - CF,RF) | 383 | +44 |
| 340 | Marcelo Mayer (BOS - 2B,3B) | 401 | +61 |
| 342 | Gavin Sheets (SD - 1B,LF,RF,DH) | 413 | +71 |
| 345 | Dylan Beavers (BAL - LF,RF,DH) | 406 | +61 |
| 347 | Moises Ballesteros (CHC - C,DH) | 418 | +71 |
| 352 | Kirby Yates (LAA - RP) IL15 | 364 | +12 |
| 354 | Luisangel Acuna (CWS - 2B,SS,CF) | 373 | +19 |
| 355 | Bo Naylor (CLE - C) | 380 | +25 |
| 356 | Austin Hays (CWS - LF,DH) IL10 | 369 | +13 |
| 358 | Joey Ortiz (MIL - SS) | 389 | +31 |
| 359 | Connor Norby (MIA - 1B,3B) | 402 | +43 |
| 362 | Isaac Collins (KC - LF,RF) | 407 | +45 |
| 364 | Victor Vodnik (COL - RP) | 394 | +30 |
| 366 | Mike Yastrzemski (ATL - LF,CF,RF) | 393 | +27 |
| 370 | Lars Nootbaar (STL - LF,CF,RF) IL60 | 428 | +58 |
| 372 | Jake Mangum (PIT - LF,CF,RF) | 445 | +73 |
| 373 | Nolan Gorman (STL - 2B,3B,DH) | 420 | +47 |
| 378 | Carson Kelly (CHC - C) | 395 | +17 |
| 384 | Victor Caratini (MIN - C,1B,DH) | 412 | +28 |
| 388 | Jared Triolo (PIT - 1B,2B,3B,SS) IL10 | 405 | +17 |
| 392 | Ryan McMahon (NYY - 3B) | 435 | +43 |
| 393 | Freddy Fermin (SD - C) | 426 | +33 |
| 394 | Kevin Ginkel (ARI - RP) | 440 | +46 |
| 396 | Trevor Larnach (MIN - LF,RF,DH) | 443 | +47 |
| 401 | Max Muncy (ATH - 2B,3B,SS) | 439 | +38 |
| 402 | Brady House (WSH - 3B) | 432 | +30 |
| 406 | Tanner Scott (LAD - RP) | 452 | +46 |
| 412 | Robby Snelling (MIA - SP) MiLB | 442 | +30 |
| 418 | Patrick Bailey (SF - C) | 446 | +28 |
