Skip Navigation to Main Content

Fantasy Baseball Trade Value Chart: Week 4

Fantasy Baseball Trade Value Chart: Week 4
Matt Chapman’s hot start has his value on the rise.

Moreso than performances, injuries can have a massive impact on your team needs. You may leave the draft projected to lead the league in home runs based on historical standings, but that does not factor in missing Aaron Judge or Giancarlo Stanton for several weeks.

Particularly with the 10-day injured list, fantasy owners are forced to make tough decisions frequently with their rosters. Rather than cutting injured players, the best bet may be to try to clear roster space by working the trade market.

As you’ll see, plenty of players saw their values rise or fall based on recent injury news, while other players have forced changes to their trade values based on early-season performances. These developments are why the trade chart is updated each and every week. So before you make any deal, make sure to consult this week’s iteration to maximize your return.

Import your team to My Playbook for season-long advice partner-arrow

Player Current Value Previous Value +/-
Mike Trout 70 71 -1
Mookie Betts 63 63 –
Jose Ramirez 63 63 –
Christian Yelich 63 63 –
Jose Altuve 61 58 3
Nolan Arenado 59 58 1
Max Scherzer 58 62 -4
J.D. Martinez 58 58 –
Bryce Harper 58 58 –
Alex Bregman 57 57 –
Javier Baez 57 51 6
Trevor Story 57 57 –
Manny Machado 55 57 -2
Ronald Acuna Jr. 55 55 –
Paul Goldschmidt 55 55 –
Charlie Blackmon 53 48 5
Freddie Freeman 53 53 –
Trevor Bauer 53 53 –
Jacob deGrom 53 58 -5
Justin Verlander 53 53 –
Blake Snell 51 53 -2
Anthony Rendon 48 48 –
Adalberto Mondesi 48 47 1
Francisco Lindor 44 31 13
Gerrit Cole 44 48 -4
Corey Kluber 44 44 –
Aaron Nola 44 44 –
Whit Merrifield 44 44 –
Khris Davis 43 42 1
Cody Bellinger 41 40 1
Andrew Benintendi 39 39 –
Chris Sale 39 39 –
Rhys Hoskins 39 39 –
Trea Turner 38 38 –
Clayton Kershaw 36 36 –
Juan Soto 35 34 1
George Springer 35 33 2
Noah Syndergaard 34 39 -5
Carlos Carrasco 34 36 -2
James Paxton 34 34 –
Anthony Rizzo 33 33 –
Joey Gallo 31 26 5
Xander Bogaerts 31 31 –
Starling Marte 30 39 -9
Kris Bryant 27 27 –
Eddie Rosario 27 17 10
J.T. Realmuto 27 26 1
Zack Greinke 27 27 –
Stephen Strasburg 27 27 –
Patrick Corbin 27 27 –
Chris Archer 26 26 –
Eugenio Suarez 24 27 -3
Joey Votto 24 26 -2
Nelson Cruz 24 23 1
Walker Buehler 23 19 4
Luis Castillo 23 21 2
Jose Abreu 23 23 –
Ozzie Albies 23 23 –
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. 23 21 2
Tommy Pham 22 17 5
Victor Robles 22 17 5
Carlos Correa 21 23 -2
Lorenzo Cain 21 26 -5
Gary Sanchez 20 19 1
Jameson Taillon 20 20 –
Jose Berrios 20 20 –
Matt Chapman 20 13 7
Giancarlo Stanton 19 24 -5
Jack Flaherty 19 19 –
Kenley Jansen 19 19 –
Edwin Diaz 19 19 –
Yoan Moncada 19 19 –
Yasmani Grandal 19 15 4
Willson Contreras 19 15 4
Elvis Andrus 17 12 5
Aaron Judge 17 55 -38
Marcell Ozuna 16 16 –
Matt Carpenter 15 15 –
Fernando Tatis Jr. 15 9 6
Jonathan Villar 15 17 -2
Yasiel Puig 15 15 –
Andrew McCutchen 15 15 –
Travis Shaw 15 14 1
Tyler Glasnow 15 15 –
German Marquez 15 15 –
David Price 15 12 3
Roberto Osuna 15 15 –
Blake Treinen 15 15 –
Brad Hand 15 15 –
Aroldis Chapman 14 14 –
Kirby Yates 14 14 –
Felipe Vazquez 13 13 –
Charlie Morton 13 15 -2
A.J. Pollock 13 13 –
Michael Conforto 13 13 –
Mitch Haniger 13 12 1
Mike Moustakas 12 14 -2
Shane Bieber 12 12 –
Josh Donaldson 12 12 –
Zack Wheeler 12 6 6
Miles Mikolas 12 12 –
Daniel Murphy 12 7 5
Tim Anderson 12 9 3
David Dahl 12 9 3
Wil Myers 11 11 –
Pete Alonso 11 10 1
Jean Segura 11 15 -4
Josh Hader 10 11 -1
Wilson Ramos 10 9 1
Corey Seager 10 15 -5
Gleyber Torres 10 11 -1
Dee Gordon 9 7 2
Paul DeJong 9 5 4
Madison Bumgarner 9 12 -3
Chris Paddack 9 2 7
Cole Hamels 8 6 2
Mallex Smith 8 7 1
Edwin Encarnacion 8 10 -2
Raisel Iglesias 8 8 –
Justin Turner 7 8 -1
Robinson Cano 7 7 –
Carlos Santana 7 7 –
Joe Musgrove 7 6 1
Eloy Jimenez 7 11 -4
Sean Doolittle 6 6 –
Wade Davis 6 6 –
Jordan Hicks 6 6 –
Max Muncy 6 7 -1
Michael Brantley 6 6 –
Jose Leclerc 6 8 -2
Ken Giles 6 6 –
Masahiro Tanaka 6 6 –
Robbie Ray 6 6 –
Matthew Boyd 6 5 1
Rougned Odor 6 5 1
Craig Kimbrel 6 11 -5
Collin McHugh 6 N/A 6
Sonny Gray 6 5 1
David Peralta 6 6 –
Yu Darvish 5 6 -1
Byron Buxton 5 2 3
Stephen Piscotty 5 4 1
Caleb Smith 5 3 2
Kyle Hendricks 5 5 –
Buster Posey 5 4 1
Yadier Molina 5 5 –
Jose Peraza 5 8 -3
Domingo Santana 4 4 –
Jose Quintana 4 4 –
Rich Hill 4 4 –
Nomar Mazara 4 4 –
Mike Foltynewicz 4 5 -1
Jorge Polanco 4 2 2
Ryan Braun 4 4 –
Mike Clevinger 4 4 –
Luis Severino 4 4 –
Hyun-Jin Ryu 4 4 –
Gregory Polanco 4 2 2
Nicholas Castellanos 4 4 –
Austin Meadows 4 5 -1
Jon Gray 4 4 –
Luke Weaver 4 N/A 4
Josh Bell 4 3 1
Jose Alvarado 4 5 -1
Greg Holland 4 4 –
Pedro Strop 4 N/A 4
Alex Colome 4 4 –
Luke Voit 4 2 2
Eduardo Rodriguez 3 4 -1
Kenta Maeda 3 4 -1
Carlos Rodon 3 2 1
Aaron Hicks 3 3 –
Ryan McMahon 3 N/A 3
Brad Peacock 3 4 -1
A.J. Minter 3 3 –
Ender Inciarte 3 4 -1
Shohei Ohtani 3 3 –
J.A. Happ 3 3 –
Adam Jones 3 4 -1
Christian Walker 3 N/A 3
Cody Allen 2 4 -2
Maikel Franco 2 2 –
Yandy Diaz 2 2 –
Merrill Kelly 2 N/A 2
Jake Arrieta 2 2 –
Jesus Aguilar 2 4 -2
Jonathan Schoop 2 2 –
Rafael Devers 2 2 –
Ramon Laureano 2 2 –
Eric Hosmer 2 2 –
Cesar Hernandez 2 N/A 2
Jesse Winker 2 2 –
Brian Dozier 2 2 –
Franmil Reyes 2 2 –
Jake Bauers 2 2 –
Kike Hernandez 2 2 –
Billy Hamilton 2 N/A 2
Shin-Soo Choo 2 N/A 2
Marcus Semien 2 N/A 2
Hunter Dozier 2 N/A 2

 
Aaron Judge’s “seriously strained” oblique is going to cost him quite a bit of playing time, and whenever he does return, he’s likely going to need a bit of time to get back in the swing of things. Players who suffer long-term injuries are always difficult to value, as even their best-case scenario leaves question marks. Worse than that, new injuries have a way of cropping up, such as Luis Severino’s lat strain or, more pertinent this week, Giancarlo Stanton’s shoulder injury. Stanton received a cortisone shot, which means his return is likely delayed for several weeks. His value drops accordingly, as does Starling Marte’s, whose abdominal injury should keep him on the shelf for a few weeks, though he is reportedly making progress.

Those who saw their values rise based on performance include Matt Chapman, whose drop in strikeout rate and continued overall positive strides have made him one of the early favorites for MVP, and Joey Gallo, who is hitting the ball with more authority than perhaps anyone in the game. Eddie Rosario’s power surge, Willson Contreras’ fly-ball rate, Chris Paddack’s refusal to allow hits, and Fernando Tatis Jr.’s success in the leadoff spot all result in an increase in trade value.

As for those seeing their trade values fall, Noah Syndergaard has yet to show that he’s capable of just rearing back and letting things fly rather than nibbling at the plate, and Craig Kimbrel went from signing imminently to all quiet on the Western front. Finally, with Vladimir Guerrero Jr. getting the call to the big leagues, it’s worth noting that Eloy Jimenez has had a rather quiet 2019 season thus far. His talent remains, but his performance has not matched his name recognition.

Import your team to My Playbook for custom advice all season partner-arrow


Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Google Play | SoundCloud | Stitcher | TuneIn

Dan Harris is a featured writer for FantasyPros. For more from Dan, check out his archive or follow him on Twitter @danharris80.

More Articles

MLB DFS Picks & Underdog Player Props: Sunday (9/27)

MLB DFS Picks & Underdog Player Props: Sunday (9/27)

fp-headshot by Corey Pieper | 4 min read
MLB DFS Picks & Underdog Player Props: Saturday (9/26)

MLB DFS Picks & Underdog Player Props: Saturday (9/26)

fp-headshot by Corey Pieper | 4 min read
MLB DFS Picks & Underdog Player Props: Friday (9/25)

MLB DFS Picks & Underdog Player Props: Friday (9/25)

fp-headshot by Josh Shepardson | 4 min read
10 Fantasy Baseball Prospects to Stash in Keeper Leagues (2026)

10 Fantasy Baseball Prospects to Stash in Keeper Leagues (2026)

fp-headshot by Brett Ussery | 3 min read

About Author